Ollie Pope’s early dismissal on day two of the third Ashes Test in Adelaide left England reeling and put his position in the team under renewed scrutiny. After a promising start to the series, Pope once again struggled against Australia, failing to convert opportunities into meaningful contributions.
The 27-year-old’s brief innings highlighted the recurring issues that have plagued him in Australia. From a tight lbw decision going against him to miscues against familiar bowlers, Pope’s recent performances echo past struggles in Brisbane and elsewhere.
Former teammates and analysts note that Pope may be overthinking at the crease, trying too hard to make a mark, which leads to rushed shots and uncharacteristic mistakes. His batting average at number three has dipped below 40 for the first time since he assumed the role in 2022, a sharp contrast to his early promise in that position.
Despite flashes of brilliance, including a 196 against India in Hyderabad in 2024 and another century earlier this year at Headingley, Pope’s consistency has been a concern. Against Australia specifically, he has yet to register a fifty in 15 innings, averaging just 17.66, a statistic highlighting the challenge of performing against the hosts.
Injuries, shifting team dynamics, and competition from younger players like Jacob Bethell have added pressure. Pope also had the vice-captaincy removed before the Ashes, further complicating his role and confidence. England’s management have debated squad options, leaving Pope in a precarious position where his next innings could determine whether he retains his spot at number three.
Former England captain Michael Vaughan suggests alternatives, including moving Pope down the order and employing him as a wicketkeeper, where he has an impressive record over six Tests. Yet the immediate focus remains on his performance at number three: with the Ashes on the line, Pope may have just one chance to prove he belongs in the middle order.
